Walk away or accept the price cut?

A lower offer is worth accepting when it leaves you more, after the agent’s fee, than relisting is likely to: another fee, months of costs while you wait, and the chance the next sale falls through too. Put in your own figures to see which comes out ahead, and the offer at which the two are level.

Your figures

Use figures you have in writing where you can. The two defaults come from the government’s own figures; change them if you know better.

The offer

From your memorandum of sale.

Their new figure, in writing via your agent.

Fill in this or the new offer; you don’t need both.

If you relist

Ask your agent for comparables, and check what similar homes sold for with HM Land Registry’s free search. Leave blank to use the agreed price.

Your agent’s honest estimate for your street and price.

The government puts the average at around 120 days from offer accepted to completion, about 4 months (MHCLG reform roadmap, June 2026).

The same roadmap says around one in 3 transactions fall through: 33%. Change it if you have better information.

Costs

Your agency contract. Citizens Advice says commission can vary from less than 1% to 3.5%.

Check your contract. The standard rate is 20% (GOV.UK).

Only costs you wouldn’t have if you completed now: rent or bridging interest, a second mortgage, bills on an empty home.

New photos or marketing, a new EPC if yours has expired, extra legal work for a new buyer. Leave blank if there are none.

JavaScript is off in this browser, so the calculator can’t work out a result. The method is written out under How it works, with an example, and works with a pen and paper.

Your result

Your result shows here when you choose Work it out.

How it works

It compares the two paths open to you, with the method of the kit’s Walk-away tab:

  • Accept: the buyer’s new offer, less the agent’s fee on it.
  • Relist: the price you’d expect from a new buyer, less the agent’s fee on that, less your extra monthly costs for the months you’d wait, less the one-off costs of starting again.

The months you’d wait are the months to find a buyer plus the months from offer to completion, increased by the chance that the next sale falls through as well. It is a planning allowance, not a forecast.

The break-even offer is the offer that would leave you exactly what relisting is expected to, after the agent’s fee. Above it, accepting comes out ahead; below it, relisting does. The agreed price less the break-even offer is the largest cut worth accepting on your figures.

An example. In the kit’s Example 1 the buyer cuts an agreed £350,000 to £335,000. The agent charges 1.2% plus VAT; relisting should fetch £345,000 after 2 months to find a buyer and 4 to complete, with the 33% fall-through allowance, £250 a month of extra costs and £1,200 to relaunch. Accepting leaves £330,176 and relisting about £336,837, so the break-even offer is £341,758 and the largest cut worth accepting is £8,242. On those figures relisting comes out ahead. It is fictional, and predicts nothing about any real sale.

What it leaves out

  • Your onward purchase. If you’re buying too, relisting can cost you the home you’re buying and the money already spent on it.
  • Your mortgage offer. If a new completion would come after it expires, a new offer can cost new fees.
  • A fixed-fee agent, and moving costs caused by the delay: lost removal deposits, storage, rebooking.
  • Everything that isn’t money: a school place, a job move, how much more of this you can take. Only you can weigh those.

Whatever you decide, nothing binds until exchange: put an agreed price through both conveyancers with an exchange date attached. Our free guides cover responding to a gazunder, renegotiating after a survey, a down valuation and a buyer who pulled out.

Sources